CIA waterboarded Abu Zubaydah, then admitted he wasn't the al-Qaeda leader it claimed

Image from Democracy Now! coverage: Abu Zubaydah's 40 drawings document CIA torture at black sites; corroborated by 2014 Senate report an…
Image: Democracy Now!
01 · What happened

Abu Zubaydah, the first CIA detainee waterboarded after 9/11, produced roughly 40 drawings from memory depicting his treatment (waterboarding, 'walling,' coffin-like confinement, sleep deprivation, sexual humiliation) at black sites in Thailand, Poland and Lithuania and at Guantanamo, 2002-2006. They were compiled by his attorney, Seton Hall law professor Mark Denbeaux, and UCSF's Dr. Jess Ghannam into the 2023 report 'American Torturers: FBI and CIA Abuses at Dark Sites and Guantanamo,' and were covered by The Guardian, Democracy Now! and others. The details align with the declassified 2014 Senate Intelligence Committee torture report, and the CIA and FBI have acknowledged that Zubaydah's initial designation as a senior al-Qaeda figure was mistaken.

02 · Sources · 4
Reader Supported NewsEd Pilkington's Guardian article on the drawings, syndicated here; independent established coverage.
Democracy Now!Independent broadcast news coverage with interviews.
SourceDocumentThe actual report/drawings compilation -- primary document.
SourceDocumentOfficial congressional document corroborating CIA torture program details.
03 · Response
Central Intelligence Agency

Contacted and made an on-record admission — exact wording not on record.

On-record admission
Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)

Not yet contacted for this story.

Not yet contacted
04 · What happened next · 1
Sep 17, 2026Progress

A Guantanamo Periodic Review Board held a hearing on Abu Zubaydah's continued detention without charge; his lawyers said the military's chief prosecutor considers charges unlikely, and the board issued no immediate decision. Source ↗

I saw an update